• 0 Posts
  • 8 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 16th, 2023

help-circle

  • Personally I find the meta-question more interesting than the question here. Your take is pretty much the majority one in any Western society today (albeit particularly thoughtfully expressed here). Personally I share your analysis right down the line. But you’re asking to be talked out of it. Is it because you feel that it’s not presentable here? Or maybe among your friends? Who perhaps might belong to the small minority (7%) of the US population that pollsters categorize as “progressive activists”? Just a thought.

    In any case, steelmanning is a great technique to practice. Well done for having a go.



  • Since I’m not a psychologist or even (alas) particularly empathetic, I will leave aside the fact that this post appears to be a veiled cry for help, and answer the actual question.

    Prison exists to protect society from dangerous individuals, but also because it’s the simplest form of non-corporal punishment. Flogging and flaying and chopping and mutilating and so on are all well and good but at some point in humanity’s march to civilization such things will start making the rulers queasy and it becomes more palatable to just lock the problem up for a while.

    Personally I have a radically liberal take on this. I think that the purpose of punishment (other than protection, as mentioned) should be not retribution but rather restoration. In my ideal world, prison sentences would mostly be swapped for various forms of community service.