CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) is pretty much the most empirically validated form of effective treatment for a wide variety of people, with a wide range of disorders / problems.
It is also so straightforward that many people who are not in serious mental anguish / disordered thinking can just actually do it on their own after a few actual talk sessions, by following some steps and rules that can fit on a few pages of paper.
Much of the history of psychology as a field is built on theories that are not testable, do not allow for a way to do a test that would affirm or negate the actual validity of theory.
To add more fun to this:
Turns out the fundamental theory behind why SSRIs… work… is basically bunk, woefully incorrect at best.
Almost every single study on the efficacy of SSRIs in treating what they are prescribed to treat is either funded or conducted… by the people selling them, the drug companies.
And they almost never do long term studies, and they almost always massively downplay the severity and prevalence of side effects, which often don’t arise until after long term usage.
Remeber when we had an opiod crisis because the Sackler family and other drug companies heavily pushed low quality research and recommendations onto doctors?
Studies similar to this one have become more and more common in the last few years, with it basicslly looking like SSRIs are either no more effective than placebo, or are nearly imperceptively better, just barely outside of statistically equivalent, or that they are better than placebo, but only for a completely unpredictable subset of people.
Psychiatrists have been very vehemently arguing about this crisis for the last few years, usually not in public, but uh, they don’t like to state it as bluntly as I just have, because if it turns out SSRIs and many other mind altering pharmacueticals… don’t actually treat what they are intended to, that they don’t actually work in the ways they tell their patients they do… but do very clearly cause negative side effects… well that’d mean they’ve basically been doing medical malpractice their whole careers.
The issue with CBT is that there are populations that it is not effective for, but because it’s so easy to apply that’s what the majority of professionals are trained to (only) provide. It’s not trauma informed at all - there’s little understanding of how to treat trauma in general. (Considering that ~1 in 4 women and ~1 in 6 men experience sexual violence - why is treating sexual trauma not prioritized in research?)
I have issues with rumination, and CBT makes it substantially worse. I have told every professional that I have worked with that I know it does not work for me, and instead of respecting that, I get stealth attempts at it or they do end up giving me the fucking worksheets.
CBT also can work like a kind of gaslighting - ie, right now I’m terrified of leaving the house because my drivers license is now invalid by state law and EO - my county’s jail has killed quite a few people and a little gay trans man like me is not going to do well. I can’t “replace” that thought with a better one. Ranking how I feel about that just makes me more freaked out.
I have told every professional that I have worked with that I know it does not work for me, and instead of respecting that, I get stealth attempts at it or they do end up giving me the fucking worksheets.
That is some fucking horseshit right there, in a just world you’d be able to easily sue such clowns for malpractice or at least submit a complaint that would actually lead to re-training or re-certification or something for these assholes.
I’m not trying to say CBT is a perfect panacea of mental health, just that its … basically an example of the field of therapeutic psychology not even really having any real empirical validity until fairly recently.
The mental health care system is just as, if not more broken than the rest of our healthcare system.
Absolutely full of people faking or overstating their qualifications, just doing literal fraud, or what isn’t technically legal fraud, but should be considered as such.
Its a clusterfuck, designed primarily to extract money, wase time, deliver subpar treatment.
ie, right now I’m terrified of leaving the house because my drivers license is now invalid by state law and EO - my county’s jail has killed quite a few people and a little gay trans man like me is not going to do well. I can’t “replace” that thought with a better one. Ranking how I feel about that just makes me more freaked out.
I sympathize and empathize with that… I’m not gay or trans, but I’ve spent a year or so crippled and homeless, no id, no phone, all your shit stolen every month, getting assaulted every other week… I know what its like to live in constant fear.
… Your concerns are extremely real, and any decent doctor would look to identify and then alleviate the source, the cause of the problem.
I wish I had a solution for you.
… We’re gonna need to build an underground railroad to get people into at least bluer areas…
Had I the money, and properly functioning legs, I’d rent a car for a week and drive you myself.
Fuck, I dunno, you might be able to successfully apply for asylum in Canada… you might be able to make a decent case you’re a directly targeted minority by their asylum seeker guidelines.
CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) is pretty much the most empirically validated form of effective treatment for a wide variety of people, with a wide range of disorders / problems.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3584580/
It is also so straightforward that many people who are not in serious mental anguish / disordered thinking can just actually do it on their own after a few actual talk sessions, by following some steps and rules that can fit on a few pages of paper.
https://positivepsychology.com/cbt-cognitive-behavioral-therapy-techniques-worksheets/
I am not disagreeing with you though.
Much of the history of psychology as a field is built on theories that are not testable, do not allow for a way to do a test that would affirm or negate the actual validity of theory.
To add more fun to this:
Turns out the fundamental theory behind why SSRIs… work… is basically bunk, woefully incorrect at best.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/denying-to-the-grave/202209/we-still-dont-know-how-antidepressants-work
Almost every single study on the efficacy of SSRIs in treating what they are prescribed to treat is either funded or conducted… by the people selling them, the drug companies.
And they almost never do long term studies, and they almost always massively downplay the severity and prevalence of side effects, which often don’t arise until after long term usage.
Remeber when we had an opiod crisis because the Sackler family and other drug companies heavily pushed low quality research and recommendations onto doctors?
https://www.bmj.com/content/378/bmj-2021-067606
Studies similar to this one have become more and more common in the last few years, with it basicslly looking like SSRIs are either no more effective than placebo, or are nearly imperceptively better, just barely outside of statistically equivalent, or that they are better than placebo, but only for a completely unpredictable subset of people.
Psychiatrists have been very vehemently arguing about this crisis for the last few years, usually not in public, but uh, they don’t like to state it as bluntly as I just have, because if it turns out SSRIs and many other mind altering pharmacueticals… don’t actually treat what they are intended to, that they don’t actually work in the ways they tell their patients they do… but do very clearly cause negative side effects… well that’d mean they’ve basically been doing medical malpractice their whole careers.
Whoops!
The issue with CBT is that there are populations that it is not effective for, but because it’s so easy to apply that’s what the majority of professionals are trained to (only) provide. It’s not trauma informed at all - there’s little understanding of how to treat trauma in general. (Considering that ~1 in 4 women and ~1 in 6 men experience sexual violence - why is treating sexual trauma not prioritized in research?)
I have issues with rumination, and CBT makes it substantially worse. I have told every professional that I have worked with that I know it does not work for me, and instead of respecting that, I get stealth attempts at it or they do end up giving me the fucking worksheets.
CBT also can work like a kind of gaslighting - ie, right now I’m terrified of leaving the house because my drivers license is now invalid by state law and EO - my county’s jail has killed quite a few people and a little gay trans man like me is not going to do well. I can’t “replace” that thought with a better one. Ranking how I feel about that just makes me more freaked out.
That is some fucking horseshit right there, in a just world you’d be able to easily sue such clowns for malpractice or at least submit a complaint that would actually lead to re-training or re-certification or something for these assholes.
I’m not trying to say CBT is a perfect panacea of mental health, just that its … basically an example of the field of therapeutic psychology not even really having any real empirical validity until fairly recently.
The mental health care system is just as, if not more broken than the rest of our healthcare system.
Absolutely full of people faking or overstating their qualifications, just doing literal fraud, or what isn’t technically legal fraud, but should be considered as such.
Its a clusterfuck, designed primarily to extract money, wase time, deliver subpar treatment.
I sympathize and empathize with that… I’m not gay or trans, but I’ve spent a year or so crippled and homeless, no id, no phone, all your shit stolen every month, getting assaulted every other week… I know what its like to live in constant fear.
… Your concerns are extremely real, and any decent doctor would look to identify and then alleviate the source, the cause of the problem.
I wish I had a solution for you.
… We’re gonna need to build an underground railroad to get people into at least bluer areas…
Had I the money, and properly functioning legs, I’d rent a car for a week and drive you myself.
Fuck, I dunno, you might be able to successfully apply for asylum in Canada… you might be able to make a decent case you’re a directly targeted minority by their asylum seeker guidelines.